Maniac's QUALITY anime log

[Maniac234678]

I'll just quote it so that I may witness its glory for a bit longer.

and now some lol





massive arc 3 spoilers, and massive QUALITY

http://i278.photobucket.com/albums/kk98/ReinforceEin/vlcsnap-417564.png

What a great way to open the next page.

If I fail at everything, you have to be a singularity of failure by comparison.

[Maniac234678]

Still the most wtf thing in the Umineko anime.

[Maniac234678]

http://myanimelist.net/people/8700/Adolf_Hitler

More talented than Nasu tbqf

[Maniac234678]

I found an Umineko anime box-set (Made up of about a third of the episodes) being sold for $320. Whoever is in charge of that decision has an... interesting perception of how demand works. Especially since you could buy each individual Umineko game, the two spin-offs and the PS3 port for about $70 less than that price.

Oh hey, the purpose of my topic has become "bash a crappy 1.5 year old adaptation."

[Fuuka Yamagishi]

i thought that was most of what you did

[Marie Rose]

ha

[Maniac234678]

MAL rating adjustments:

Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha A's - 9 (+1)
Detroit Metal City - 8 (+1)
Sketchbook: Full Color's - 8 (+1)
Black Lagoon - 7 (+1)
Gunbuster - 4 (+1)
The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya - 4 (-1)
Shakugan no Shana - 3 (-1)

New scores (none of these are complete, so they can change):

One Piece - 8
Hayate no Gotoku - 7
Jigoku Shoujo - 7
ARIA the Animation - 7
Slayers - 6
Sora no Woto - 6
Darker than Black - 5
Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha StrikerS - 5
Umineko no Naku Koro ni - 4

Also removed tags and added somewhat more detailed comments to everything that's not on hold or on the watchlist, but people care even less about that.

Any comments?

[Marie Rose]

Why is The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya low?

[Maniac234678]

I only enjoyed one episode, and found the rest of it painfully boring.

[Marie Rose]

Understandable.

[Maniac234678]

Also, admittedly, I watched the chronological order, which has a **** terrible ending. I swear that the point of the chronological order was just to sell more DVDs. >_>

[Marie Rose]

Yeah, that one episode in the middle made a better ending. Episode 6 chronologically I think it was.

[Maniac234678]

That was the ending of the broadcast order, though. I should have went with that.

Broadcast order also had the best episode as the first one, so that's cool as well.

[Esh]

I only enjoyed one episode, and found the rest of it painfully boring.

I know there's no way it would be but.... If it was endless eight.... I would have laughed so hard.... I might of died....

Yeah chronological order sucks.... I mean the last episode becomes one where almost nothing happens.... There's like a whole scene where nothing happens....

But I do not approve of your scores.... I don't care to explain further.... But feel free to mock me for my tastes.... In fact I'm looking forward to it.... I enjoy it on a strange creepy level.... There's something wrong with me....

[Maniac234678]

Just tell me which scores are the ones that you disapprove, I'll figure it out on my own,

Also, I never watched anything after the first season. What I did see was so painfully insipid that I won't ever plan on watching more.